Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 43
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

quote:
Originally posted by JJZ:

quote:
Originally posted by ball junkie:

We'll have to agree to disagree about the roster. No disrespect to your opinion but when Magic beat writer's begin writing about our team's personnel flaws that speaks "volumes" to me. They study the team for a living. It's their job.

 

It's like if I'm going to choose to go to counseling for problems in my marriage I'm not going to go to a person that has no experience.

 

Beat writer's have a lot of experience studying the game and more specifically this team.

 

None of these guys were saying anything bad about our roster earlier in the year. Now that we're losing, they're just jumping on what seems the obvious bandwagon. These particular guys apparently have no ability to look below the surface.

 

As a physician, I know when someone presents with pain in their abdomen, it doesn't have to be due to a stomach problem. It could be the gallbladder, intestine, kidney, pancreas or even the heart. The seemingly obvious "answer" is often wrong.

 

Do these "analysts" really think blowing up our roster every year or two will bring us success?

 

When you say "blow up" are you talking about getting rid of everybody except Dwight?

 

I really don't think the writer's are suggesting that. But, I think it's become quite obvious that a good portion of our team's problem's stem from the ability of our roster to produce and even more so their mental resolve.

 

We need more mentally tough players. We have no one on our roster that will get in somebody's face! It can't always come from the coach.

 

Who do we have on the roster that will lead us and get on someone's butt?

 

Answer?

Posted

quote:
Originally posted by Drunk on Mystery:

I just got back from the game. I was sitting behind one end of the court, near the magic bench. Some observations:

 

Grant Hill is too old and too slow to be getting ISOs called for him. He can't beat anyone off the dribble, so every time he got one, he'd pull up for a jumper.

 

Battie played with no tenacity at all tonight. He was just standing around, and got pushed around by his man the entire game. If tonight was a game to see who should start, him or Darko, Darko wins. Speaking of...

 

Darko played with more intensity than I've seen from him all year. I'd go so far as to say that only Trevor and JJ played harder than he did tonight. He fought for loose balls and rebounds, and was all over Rahim on defense.

 

Trevor needs to start yesterday. He's simply more athletic, quicker, and stronger than anyone else the magic have at the 3, and plays defense better than anyone on the team.

 

Just having JJ on the court makes the offense better, because JJ's man has to stay on him, or he'll get burned. That frees up the inside a great deal.

 

Adding to that, JJ plays harder than anyone else on the court, including Trevor. He's at full sprint pretty much every second he's on the court. As far as his defense goes: yes, he gets beat occassionaly, but he's better than Nelson, Arroyo or Hedo, and he plays a lot harder on D than any of those guys do, so I see no reason not to give him 20+ minutes a game.

 

Nelson was great in the first half, but looked bad in the third. When the offense isn't clicking, Nelson tries to force it himself. That's a youth thing that I think he'll grow out of with time.

 

Little Napoleon's offensive schemes were outdated 10 years ago. My dad, who I was at the game with, referred to it as the "Dump and watch" plan, as they dump it into Dwight, and just watch him get triple teamed. After Dwight would get the ball, the only players on the Magic who would move were Trevor, JJ, and Darko when he was on the court. It was tragic.

 

If I'm Otis, I'm asking Brian Hill tomorrow morning what his rotation is for next year, assuming everyone is back, and then I'm trading a lot of people away.

Posted

quote:
Originally posted by FENDI:

Grant was useless? I'm sure anybody on this team would be useless when guarded by Ron Artest.

 

Its a poor shooting night and lack of execution. Signs of a young team.

 

Agreed, whoever Artest guards is going to have a bad night.

 

I didn't get to watch the game but I will say this, we haven't paid attention to the problems with the offense all year and once again we lose a game because we are unable to put points on the board enough to offset a defensive collaspe. Players, coaches, whatever, the offense is terrible and the leader of that offense (the coach) has been quoted as saying that he is more concerned about the defense because the offense will take care of itself. When exactly is it going to start taking care of itself?

Posted

quote:
Originally posted by Marc Acres 3:16:

quote:
Originally posted by FENDI:

Grant was useless? I'm sure anybody on this team would be useless when guarded by Ron Artest.

 

Its a poor shooting night and lack of execution. Signs of a young team.

 

Agreed, whoever Artest guards is going to have a bad night.

 

I didn't get to watch the game but I will say this, we haven't paid attention to the problems with the offense all year and once again we lose a game because we are unable to put points on the board enough to offset a defensive collaspe. Players, coaches, whatever, the offense is terrible and the leader of that offense (the coach) has been quoted as saying that he is more concerned about the defense because the offense will take care of itself. When exactly is it going to start taking care of itself?

 

I agree Marc. But don't you think our roster flaws is a major part of our offensive troubles? I mean as I was watching the game last night from behind the basket I was sitting there wondering, "who can we go to right now to get points"? I'm referring to the strech where we went stagnant.

 

I agree with Brian. A good agressive defense can create all kinds of good offense. Look no further than the Utah game last Wednesday.

Posted

The Magic made the Kings defense look like the San Antonio Spurs last night. I saw the same problems with the offense that I see almost everytime they play including the Jazz game. Eventually the Magic offense is going to get stagnant and the other team will go on a run.

 

I agree with alot of what Smack says. I don't understand how a lineup of Hill and Ariza works. It would seem faily obvious to me to slide Hill back to the 3 and start JJ in the second half. If Brian Hill wants to play Dooling at the point why does he screw up his rotation but starting Dooling off at the 2 guard. I still would like to see what Diener can do on a regular basis rather than watch him on the sidelines in a suit.

 

Maybe there is something going on that I'm not aware of that is causing all the problems. All I know is only scoring 30pts in the second half against the vaunted Kings defense is completely unacceptable.

Posted

quote:
Originally posted by emory889:

The Magic made the Kings defense look like the San Antonio Spurs last night. I saw the same problems with the offense that I see almost everytime they play including the Jazz game. Eventually the Magic offense is going to get stagnant and the other team will go on a run.

 

I agree with alot of what Smack says. I don't understand how a lineup of Hill and Ariza works. It would seem faily obvious to me to slide Hill back to the 3 and start JJ in the second half. If Brian Hill wants to play Dooling at the point why does he screw up his rotation but starting Dooling off at the 2 guard. I still would like to see what Diener can do on a regular basis rather than watch him on the sidelines in a suit.

 

Maybe there is something going on that I'm not aware of that is causing all the problems. All I know is only scoring 30pts in the second half against the vaunted Kings defense is completely unacceptable.

 

Emory, if you look at my post right after Smack I adressed that question about Redick.

 

Grant Hill got 2 early fouls called on him. With his new rotation he could choose Redick or Dooling as a sub. I don't blame him one bit. A defensive backcourt of Nelson and Redick will not work. It's not that J.J. is that bad but when you pair him Jameer it's not very effective. I've been saying that since Redick was drafted.

 

When Dooling plays point it works. See the Jazz game.

 

Anyway, Hill's rotations got messed up because of that and he wasn't able to employ the line-up that was so effective against the Jazz. On top of that Turkoglu came up with his mysterious stomach flu again.

 

I noticed last night that if Redick just touched somebody they called a foul. You know the NBA. Rookies get no respect.

Posted

quote:
Originally posted by ball junkie:

Agreed, whoever Artest guards is going to have a bad night.

 

I didn't get to watch the game but I will say this, we haven't paid attention to the problems with the offense all year and once again we lose a game because we are unable to put points on the board enough to offset a defensive collaspe. Players, coaches, whatever, the offense is terrible and the leader of that offense (the coach) has been quoted as saying that he is more concerned about the defense because the offense will take care of itself. When exactly is it going to start taking care of itself?

 

I agree Marc. But don't you think our roster flaws is a major part of our offensive troubles? I mean as I was watching the game last night from behind the basket I was sitting there wondering, "who can we go to right now to get points"? I'm referring to the strech where we went stagnant.

 

I agree with Brian. A good agressive defense can create all kinds of good offense. Look no further than the Utah game last Wednesday.

 

The roster flaws are major and definately a part of why the offense stinks but, I do not believe that it is impossible to manufactor or at least maximize offense out of the players we have.

 

I've used this example before but it is a good one. Brian Billik is an offensive minded football coach, he want's to score a lot. He was stuck with a crappy QB (Dilfer) and he made it work enough where they scored just enough to win with the defense they had. We haven't made anything work, we are losing in the same way that we have been losing all year, too many turnovers, anemic offense and poor spacing.

 

Scott Skiles has had an issue with a lack of an inside scorer for quite a while now, he created an offensive game plan to use what he had and he has had some success or at least more than what we have had.

 

We do need better personel but that doesn't mean that we should have layed down and died this season.

Posted

quote:
Originally posted by Marc Acres 3:16:

quote:
Originally posted by ball junkie:

Agreed, whoever Artest guards is going to have a bad night.

 

I didn't get to watch the game but I will say this, we haven't paid attention to the problems with the offense all year and once again we lose a game because we are unable to put points on the board enough to offset a defensive collaspe. Players, coaches, whatever, the offense is terrible and the leader of that offense (the coach) has been quoted as saying that he is more concerned about the defense because the offense will take care of itself. When exactly is it going to start taking care of itself?

 

I agree Marc. But don't you think our roster flaws is a major part of our offensive troubles? I mean as I was watching the game last night from behind the basket I was sitting there wondering, "who can we go to right now to get points"? I'm referring to the strech where we went stagnant.

 

I agree with Brian. A good agressive defense can create all kinds of good offense. Look no further than the Utah game last Wednesday.

 

The roster flaws are major and definately a part of why the offense stinks but, I do not believe that it is impossible to manufactor or at least maximize offense out of the players we have.

 

I've used this example before but it is a good one. Brian Billik is an offensive minded football coach, he want's to score a lot. He was stuck with a crappy QB (Dilfer) and he made it work enough where they scored just enough to win with the defense they had. We haven't made anything work, we are losing in the same way that we have been losing all year, too many turnovers, anemic offense and poor spacing.

 

Scott Skiles has had an issue with a lack of an inside scorer for quite a while now, he created an offensive game plan to use what he had and he has had some success or at least more than what we have had.

 

We do need better personel but that doesn't mean that we should have layed down and died this season.

 

 

 

Lately there have games where I questioned the effort but I don't think that's been the case the whole season.

 

Leadership, it has to come from someone else besides the coach. I told the story earlier in the week about my college teams and guys taking leadership in spite of the coach. Getting on someone's butt when they're not doing their job.

 

Who do we have on our roster that fills that role?

Posted

quote:
Emory, if you look at my post right after Smack I adressed that question about Redick.

 

Grant Hill got 2 early fouls called on him. With his new rotation he could choose Redick or Dooling as a sub. I don't blame him one bit. A defensive backcourt of Nelson and Redick will not work. It's not that J.J. is that bad but when you pair him Jameer it's not very effective. I've been saying that since Redick was drafted.

 

When Dooling plays point it works. See the Jazz game.

 

Anyway, Hill's rotations got messed up because of that and he wasn't able to employ the line-up that was so effective against the Jazz. On top of that Turkoglu came up with his mysterious stomach flu again.

 

I noticed last night that if Redick just touched somebody they called a foul. You know the NBA. Rookies get no respect.

 

The Kings backcourt isn't big or especially fast. Bibby and Martin are good players but Jameer and JJ played them well in the first half so why wouldn't it work in the second half. JJ did make some defensive errors but it was silly ones like fouling a jump shooter. I didn't see anyone blow by JJ on defense last night and I even saw him play good post defense on 2 occasions.

 

I like what I saw from Dooling in the Jazz game. That's my point, with the previous rotation if Grant was to get in foul trouble then Dooling went in and if Jameer got into foul trouble then Arroyo would go in. I don't ever recall Brian Hill sending in Arroyo to spell Grant. So unless the coach wants Jameer to play major minutes he knows he is messing up the lineup by putting in his backup pg to play the sg. Especially when he has JJ and Bogans ready to go. That would have kept the Jazz rotations in tact.

 

After the great half that JJ had I still don't understand the logic behind starting both Grant and Ariza. Everytime I look at that lineup I see major offensive problems. That lineup has 1 shooter (Jameer), 2 slashers, Dwight, and a hustle guy in Battie. I don't see how anyone is going to score unless they manage to get fast break points.

Posted

quote:
Originally posted by ball junkie:

Lately there have games where I questioned the effort but I don't think that's been the case the whole season.

 

Leadership, it has to come from someone else besides the coach. I told the story earlier in the week about my college teams and guys taking leadership in spite of the coach. Getting on someone's butt when they're not doing their job.

 

Who do we have on our roster that fills that role?

 

No one, and that is part of the roster issue. In your example you had a poor coach but you had players that took initiative. We have a poor coach and players that have not taken the initiative. Management has decided to see what we have and see whether our players can grow into that leadership role so the only option we have is to wait on the players or have the coach get the most out of them. Every person involved with the team has some of the blame to shoulder but, rather than the coach pointing the finger at the players and saying "I don't know what else to do" someone should have stepped up and said, "we have issues but I am going to fix or make the best of them."

 

Waiting takes time, the coach needed to get the most out of them this season.

Posted

The thing with the lack of leadership is that we have guys that should be very good leaders. Battie and Oulaw seem to have all the characteristics of a good leader. Grant Hill was a leader. I watched him singlehandley haul a Duke team to the championship and he was the clear leader of that team. I saw the same things in Detroit as well. It really baffles me why Hill isn't more of a leader on this team.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...